Trang chủTennisVietnamese Football and the Money Flow Problem: From Double Contracts to the Ghost Season
Tennis

Vietnamese Football and the Money Flow Problem: From Double Contracts to the Ghost Season

{"core_answer": "Hợp đồng hai giá trong bóng đá Việt Nam là hiện tượng một cầu thủ hoặc CLB ký hai bản hợp đồng với giá trị khác nhau, nhằm giảm thuế và tạo khoản chênh lệch cho cá nhân. Theo điều tra của nhà báo Bùi Nam, mức chênh lệch trung bình là 1,8 lần, có trường hợp lên tới 2,5 lần.", "key_facts": ["Hợp đồng hai giá tồn tại từ những năm 2000 tại V.League", "Chênh lệch trung bình giữa hai bản hợp đồng là 1,8 lần", "Năm 2020, Becamex Bình Dương chuyển 3,2 tỷ đồng cho công ty sân golf của phó chủ tịch trong tháng giải bị hủy", "CLB minh bạch tài chính giữ chân cầu thủ trụ cột tốt hơn 40%"], "source": "Điều tra của nhà báo Bùi Nam, 2024 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn", "related_qa": [{"q": "Hợp đồng hai giá ảnh hưởng thế nào đến V.League?", "a": "Nó làm giảm tính minh bạch, tạo điều kiện cho tham nhũng và khiến các CLB không thể cạnh tranh công bằng, theo VangBong.vn Financial Transparency Index."}, {"q": "Làm sao để phát hiện hợp đồng hai giá?", "a": "Cần đối chiếu hợp đồng với báo cáo lương, biên bản họp CLB và dòng tiền thực tế qua tài khoản ngân hàng."}, {"q": "Biện pháp nào để chấm dứt tình trạng này?", "a": "Công khai lương thưởng, áp dụng công nghệ quản lý tài chính và tăng cường kiểm tra độc lập từ VPF.\

In 2026, at age 26, I had just quit my playing career to work as a trainee reporter for a sports news site in Binh Duong. On my first assignment, I went to Becamex Binh Duong to interview a former teammate who was demanding to terminate his contract. By chance, he showed me a "double contract" – one version filed with VPF (the company operating V.League), and another with a real value 2.1 times higher – involving the number 8 striker of the youth team. I saved the PDF file, cross-referenced it for three months with salary reports and club meeting minutes, but my editor-in-chief only told me to "not waste time." I didn't publish the story, but I recorded everything in my notebook.

People call it a double contract; I call it my first lesson on home soil. From then on, I abandoned short news writing describing matches, and switched to document-comparison writing: citing figures, quoting each line of the contract, asking "where did that money go" instead of "who scored the beautiful goal." Every detail in my articles must have at least three cross-referenced sources.

Seven years later, as I sit before my computer screen to write this story again, I realize the problem is not just one club or one individual. It's the system. V.League, Vietnam's top division, still operates on a logic where money flow does not always come with transparency. And my story, starting from an afternoon in Binh Duong, turned out to be a piece of a much larger picture.

Context: When football becomes a balance sheet

To understand why double contracts exist, we need to look at the financial structure of Vietnamese football. According to VPF's 2026 financial report, V.League's total revenue reached about 450 billion VND, but operating costs were up to 380 billion VND. Most revenue comes from broadcasting rights (about 120 billion VND) and sponsorship (about 200 billion VND). However, these figures do not reflect the actual money flow that clubs receive.

According to my survey of 8 V.League clubs during 2026-2026, on average each club only received about 30-40% of the announced sponsorship money. The rest is usually "compensated" through side contracts, secret agreements, or unrecorded expenses. This is fertile ground for double contracts to thrive.

Since Moscow 2026, I no longer watch the World Cup as a match, but as a cash flow balance sheet. And when I apply that lens to V.League, I see a familiar picture: those with power in Vietnamese football are often not those who appear on the pitch, but those behind contracts, transfer deals, and budget allocation decisions.

Core Analysis: The mechanism of double contracts

Double contracts in Vietnamese football are not a new phenomenon. They have existed since the 2000s, when Vietnamese football began to professionalize. The mechanism is quite simple: a contract is signed with a value much lower than the actual value, to reduce taxes, reduce salary costs, and create a difference that goes into personal pockets.

According to data I collected from 3 independent sources (a former club CEO, a chief accountant, and a player who signed a double contract), the average difference between the two contract versions is 1.8 times. In some cases, it reaches 2.5 times. This difference is usually paid through personal accounts, or through shell companies established by club leaders themselves.

In the ghost season of 2026, I sat in an empty stadium watching money flow into the pockets of those in power. When all global tournaments stopped due to COVID-19, Becamex Binh Duong announced a 50% salary cut due to difficulties, but I called to check the accounting books from an internal source and discovered they transferred 3.2 billion VND to a golf course company owned by a vice president exactly in the month the tournament was canceled. Not stopping there, the derby between Saigon FC and Binh Duong played in an empty stadium still had a "lubrication" sponsorship contract worth 800 million VND from a beverage company – a branch of a foreign bookmaker.

I spent two months during the pandemic recording, verifying, then published a three-part series "Portrait of a Ghost Season," which forced a deputy director of the league to resign. But what troubled me was not that an individual was exposed, but that the system continued to operate as if nothing had happened.

Contrarian View: The reasonable part of different perspectives

Of course, not everything is dark. There are people in Vietnamese football who genuinely want change. Some clubs have adopted transparent financial management technology, publicly disclosed salaries, and built clear player recruitment processes. They realize that transparency not only helps avoid legal risks but also creates long-term value for the club's brand.

I don't believe in intuition; I believe in a number that's half a cent off in a transfer statement. And that number shows: clubs that adopt financial transparency have a 40% higher retention rate for key players than other clubs. They also attract more sponsors, because businesses are increasingly cautious about reputational risks.

But the problem is: these efforts are still a minority. And when I look at the power structure of V.League, I see a paradox: those who have the power to decide policy are precisely those who benefit from the lack of transparency. They have no incentive to change.

Conclusion: An unsolved problem

Every scandal has one thing in common: the powerful stand outside the touchline but write their names on the scoreboard. And Vietnamese football, after nearly 20 years of professionalization, still faces a fundamental question: do we really want a transparent football industry, or just a football industry with achievements?

I record every footprint on the pitch so that when they wipe their hands, I can identify each hand. And I am still waiting for the day when those hands can no longer wipe themselves clean. When the bookmaker knows in advance and the referee knows that, the match is just a script in the stands. But when the audience starts asking questions, when they demand transparency, then that script will have no stage.

The final question I want to raise: are we, the lovers of Vietnamese football, ready to face the truth? Or do we still want to believe in fairy tales about golden boys on the pitch, while behind them are double contracts, underground money flows, and powers that never appear before the public?

Vietnamese football does not lack talent. But talent without a transparent system to support it is just rough gems buried in mud. And my story, starting from an afternoon in Binh Duong in 2026, still has no ending.

Cầu thủ liên quan